Chiefs have ended up as winners (including penalty shootout wins) 18 times while Pirates have gone home as winners on 16 occasions, with 22 games declared as draws at the end.
With 20 years of PSL football having been played to date, 40 of these 56 matches have been league games.
Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Mathoho) Orlando Pirates 3 (Sarr, Gcaba, Gabuza) – October 31, 2015
Orlando Pirates 1 (Gabuza) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Katsande) – January 30, 2016
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 0 (Chiefs won 6-5 on penalties after extra-time) – November 7, 2015
Orlando Pirates 2 (Ndoro 2) Kaizer Chiefs 0 – March 5, 2016
Orlando Pirates 0 Kaizer Chiefs 2 (Tshabalala Mthembu) - December 6, 2014
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 0 – March 7, 2015
Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Mashamaite) Orlando Pirates 0 - September 20, 2014
Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Nkhatha) Orlando Pirates 1 (Erasmus) – October 26, 2013
Orlando Pirates 0 Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Katsande) – March 15, 2014
First leg
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 1 (Klate) – August 24, 2013
Second leg
Orlando Pirates 1 (Bacela penalty) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Parker) – September 24, 2013
Orlando Pirates 1 (Mbesuma) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Majoro) – December 8, 2012
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 0 – March 9, 2013
Kaizer Chiefs 2 (Parker Tshabalala) Orlando Pirates 1 (Jele) – September 17, 2011
Orlando Pirates 3 (McCarthy 2 Jali) Kaizer Chiefs 2 (Tshabalala Majoro) – March 17, 2012
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 1 (Manyisa) – September 10, 2011
Orlando Pirates 1 (Otorogu) Kaizer Chiefs 3 (Klate og Musona 2) – November 13, 2010
Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Motaung Jnr) Orlando Pirates 1 (Mbuyane) – February 26, 2011
First leg
Orlando Pirates 1 (Chansa) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Musona) – September 11, 2010
Second leg
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 1 (Mashego) – September 26, 2010
Orlando Pirates 0 Kaizer Chiefs 3 (S’thembiso Ngcobo 2, Tshabalala) – December 4, 2010
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 0 – October 31, 2009
Orlando Pirates 0 Kaizer Chiefs 0 – February 20, 2010
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 0 (Chiefs won 3-0 on penalties) – April 5, 2010
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 2 (Mushangazhike Thwala) – November 15, 2008
Orlando Pirates 2 (Mashego 2) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Thwala og) – May 2, 2009
Orlando Pirates 2 (Khenyeza Zwane) Kaizer Chiefs 2 (Walaza 2) – November 24, 2007
Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Mathebula) Orlando Pirates 0 – May 10, 2008
Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Bartlett) Orlando Pirates 1 (Vilakazi) – December 9, 2006
Orlando Pirates 1 (Lekgwathi) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Djiehoua) – April 28, 2007
Kaizer Chiefs 2 Orlando Pirates 0 (Obua Schalkwyk) – October 29, 2005
Orlando Pirates 0 Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Obua) – December 10, 2004
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 0 (Chiefs won 5-3 on penalties) – May 20, 2006
Orlando Pirates 2 (Leremi Vilakazi) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Zwane) – March 30, 2004
Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Ngobese) Orlando Pirates 1 (Vilakazi) – April 30, 2005
Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Musasa) Orlando Pirates 0 – December 13, 2003
Orlando Pirates 1 (Makhanya) Kaizer Chiefs 0 – May 1, 2004
Orlando Pirates 1 (Manyathela) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Musasa) – December 7, 2002
Kaizer Chiefs 2 (Moshoeu Radebe) Orlando Pirates 0 – March 15, 2003
Orlando Pirates 1 (Lota) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Nomvete) – November 29, 2000
Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Mooki) Orlando Pirates 0 – June 9, 2001
Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Niemach) Orlando Pirates 0 – August 25, 2001
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 3 (Manyathela 2 Vilakazi) – December 15, 2001
Orlando Pirates 0 Kaizer Chiefs 0 – May 4, 2000
Orlando Pirates 1 (Lota) Kaizer Chiefs 0 – November 20, 1999
Kaizer Chiefs 2 (Nomvete 2) Orlando Pirates 2 (Lota Mkhize) – June 14, 2000
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 0 – October 10, 1998
Orlando Pirates 1 (Zuma) Kaizer Chiefs 2 (Lebese 2) – February 13, 1999
Kaizer Chiefs 3 (Ndlanya 2 Batchelor) Orlando Pirates 1 (Ngake) – October 31, 1998
Orlando Pirates 1 (Zuma) Kaizer Chiefs 0 – November 14, 1998
Orlando Pirates 1 (Ngobe) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Williams) – November 22, 1997
Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Mooki) Orlando Pirates 1 (Sikhosana) – March 7, 1998
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 1 (Sam Pam) – March 29, 1997
Kaizer Chiefs 0 Orlando Pirates 1 (Sikhosana) – January 18, 1997
Orlando Pirates 1 (Sikhosana) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Williams) – May 10, 1997
Orlando Pirates 4 (Sikhosana 3, Mkhalele) Kaizer Chiefs 1 (Modise) – November 2, 1996