Share

‘That should have been a penalty' – top ref issues Chiefs/ Milford verdict

accreditation
0:00
play article
Subscribers can listen to this article
 Kaizer Chiefs coach Cavin Johnson with players during the Nedbank Cup, Last 32 match between Kaizer Chiefs and Milford FC at FNB Stadium on February 25, 2024 in Johannesburg, South Africa.
Kaizer Chiefs coach Cavin Johnson with players during the Nedbank Cup, Last 32 match between Kaizer Chiefs and Milford FC at FNB Stadium on February 25, 2024 in Johannesburg, South Africa.
(Photo by Lefty Shivambu/Gallo Images)

Kaizer Chiefs should have been awarded another penalty during their Nedbank Cup last 32 defeat to Milford on Sunday, according to renowned former referee Victor Hlungwani. 

The two teams played to a goalless draw, forcing the match into a penalty shootout where Milford would walk away 5-4 winners at FNB Stadium. 

READ Chiefs assessment of Vilakazi's debut

The match was marred by controversial decision as Chiefs were awarded a penalty when Unathi Somabhele was adjudged to have handled the ball inside the box. Chiefs Chivaviro went on to miss his penalty.

Reviewing some of the decisions by the match officials on the day, Hlungwani revealed on SABC Sports SoccerZone, that in addition to Chivaviro’s penalty, Chiefs should have been awarded a second penalty just five minute later.

Vusumizi Mthabela had challenged Pule Mmodi just inside the box, but the referee pointed to for a free-kick, before showing Mthabela his marching orders for a second yellow.

"There is an infringement that happened, whether it's inside or outside. So we're going to have a look at it and check as to whether it happened inside or outside," Hlungwani explained on SoccerZone.  

"There is kicking an opponent there by Vusumuzi, kicking Mmodi, so now was this kick inside or outside let's zoom into it so that we can establish.

"We are happy with the card because that was reckless. 

"So, look at that recklessness, is it inside or outside? Let's put some goggles. I see is it inside or outside? You can establish that this happened inside [the box].

"Therefore, a penalty should have been given but the referee there took it outside, which was supposed to be inside and inside is a penalty.

"So that should have been a penalty," the former referee added. 

ALSO READ Exclusive: How Milford hero played injured to slaughter Chiefs

The review will come as little comfort to a Chiefs side now out of the Carling Knockout, out of the MTN8 and out of the Nedbank Cup, with only the DStv Premiership title to play for.

You must be SIGNED IN to read and post comments.

Click HERE to register!

Get the best in Soccer, News and Lifestyle content with SNL24 PLUS
For 14 free days, you can have access to the best from Soccer Laduma, KickOff, Daily Sun, TrueLove and Drum. Thereafter you will be billed R29 per month. You can cancel anytime and if you cancel within 14 days you won't be billed.
Subscribe to SNL24 PLUS
heading
description
username
Show Comments ()
Who is your Debonairs Player of the Weekend?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
Ronwen Williams
75% - 86 votes
Pogiso Sanoka
15% - 17 votes
Lorenzo Gordinho
10% - 12 votes
Vote
Feedback & Complaints

Got something on your mind? Get in touch!

Get in touch!
Blow the whistle

Do you have a news tip or story you would like to share with KickOff?

Email our news team
Match Centre
All Tournaments
Live Scores
South Africa Premier League