Wrong move, Masalesa!

Feature: Lehlogonolo Masalesa's move to Orlando Pirates is a mistake

Posted: 29 August 2012 Time: 12:05 pm

Lehlogonolo Masalesa has joined Orlando Pirates on a three-year contract from Bidvest Wits, but I seriously doubt this move will benefit his career in any way.

Click HERE for the story!

There are certainly a lot more players who have joined the 'wrong' team in the current transfer window, let alone in the past. I wish, though, that Masalesa's representatives would have dissuaded him from joining Pirates.

Don't get me wrong; Pirates is a great team, but Masalesa is a future Bafana Bafana player and, at 20, he is better off playing regular football and I don't think Pirates can offer him a starting berth at this stage.

By virtue of being a defensive midfielder, he will be up against Andile Jali, Onyekachi Okonkwo, Thandani Ntshumayelo and Manti Moholo in Bucs' defensive midfield role. So, realistically, what are his chances of being a regular? Did 'Vieira', or his agent, think about that before he signed? Did they check the list of players he will compete with?

I seriously doubt they did their homework.

So let's say he joined Kaizer Chiefs, just for argument's sake. They are also a big team, but their defensive midfield is not bloated.

He would have been a direct replacement for Tinashe Nengomasha and, sooner or later, he could have filled the void left by Nengomasha. In essence, he would stand a better chance of playing at Chiefs than at Pirates.

But now the likelihood is that he will make up the numbers at Pirates.

Masalesa's transfer is not an isolated incident, though, as there are other players who have joined badly chosen teams recently, and many in the past.

Wayne Arendse springs to mind. He signed for five years with Mamelodi Sundowns – a team with four more central defenders: Siyanda Xulu, Method Mwanjale, Clayton Daniels and Alje Schut.

He may not even see the end of his contract, because down the line he won't be satisfied merely to take his fat cheque home, he will demand some game-time, often indirectly through the media.

It is high time agents put their player's interest first when they move their players and players, too, must not just be content with the prestige of playing, make that sitting on the bench, for big teams.

By Tiyani wa ka Mabasa

Do you agree with Tiyani's views? Mail your comments to tiyani.mabasa@media24.com or follow me on Twitter @TTM16.

Add New Comment

Comments Login Form

Forgotten your password?

Your comments on this story...

Dooba (Glory Reclaimed)
posted: 12:08 pm
TTM... 100% spot on!
thabisomok
posted: 12:09 pm
Wrong move,indeed.....
Gucci Man
posted: 12:09 pm
Yhooooo, Yhoooo TTM
Brace yourself for insults from Mayfair.....

1 , 2, 3.....lets go
Anonymous
posted: 12:10 pm
Hey wena TTM, are you now cleverer than the Col Dr Chairman Khoza? We all know that Jali is a wanted man oorkant, so is Manyisa. Onyekachi has a get-out clause to go back to Eastern Europe after Pirates has been booted out of Champions League. Then what?
Zane10
posted: 12:10 pm
That's a great point you made Editor, but why raise it now that Bucs signed Viera and not Chiefs?
Champ Msholozi
posted: 12:12 pm
U-Ryt Tiyani, I feel sorry for this boy.........we needed you more at Chiefs......
Mcebo
posted: 12:13 pm
TTM...what if those clubs that a player is guarranteed game time arent interested or they offering too little or worse a quarter of what other clubs are offering...remember soccer pay the bills for this boys and it is a known fact that one club I cant mention its name doesnt wanna part ways with big money, what was the player and his agent suppose to do..go to a club where he will earn R15k p.m and play every game or go to a club where if he fight for his place he will get it and pocket more than R50k p.m... I dnt think players are guarranted game time, they earn it be it that , the club they joining doesnt have a good player in that position...look at Rowen Fernandez when he joined SSU..that Williams boy benched him...lets give Maselesa a chance and see if he wont waste his chances
Khosiologyst ...2013/14 Maintaining The Glory
posted: 12:13 pm
Dear Lehlogonolo Masalesa

You are a good prospect is SA soccer, you have done well so far and you deserve all the good things coming your way,and the best with your new team.

But can you please explain the logic behind your move to Orlando Pirates, could be influenced by the following?
1. They are current champions?
2. They offered you a better deal?
3. External influences by your agent or Mr Legodi?
4. Your former teammates (Phungwayo & Myeni) influence?

I dont know, as much as i would have liked you to dawn the Gold & Black jersey i feel that you have taken a step back in your career. You have chosen a team that is packed with players who are around you age and they are much established than you in the position you play. it is no secret that OP recently signed Aubrey Ngoma who was touted the next Andile Jali, but without kicking a ball even in training session he was loaned back to Tuks. It's clear that you aquisition was not about the contribution you will make to the team,but it was about the hype that was created around you and the value there off. I see you heading to Sundowns in a year ot two to come since Kaizer Chiefs doesnt entertain the "jumble-sale shenanigans" of players.

It will be with heartache to see a talent like you being loaned to Golden Arrows and then discarded afterwards. A lesson should have been taken from the likes of Clifford Ngobeni & Papi Zothwane.

Good-luck with your current financial status, but it is with deepest regret to say R.I.P to your football career.

Kind Regards
Mgugudi: The Treble Addict
posted: 12:14 pm
Sour grapes from a KC fan. Blame Bobby & stop writting amalebe.
Filaz Roger Feutmba...Sandawana
posted: 12:14 pm
I get your point TTM, but Arendse's situation is different as teams use 2 cetral defenders. For instance, Xulu and play with Daniel's or Daniel's with Arendse, or maybe with that Alje guy. Mwanjale often plays on the right, which I hate....in fact I dont like that player at all. But I think that Alje guy will be struggling for game time, not Arendse.
El Kampion
posted: 12:15 pm
@Tiyani

I see you are one of the bitter Zebra fans...

You said the same thing about Jali when he came to Galaxy

Manqele as well

You guys can go hang yourselves with a spider web,this boy is a Buccaneer now so deal with it
Gucci Man
posted: 12:15 pm
TTM based on the below statement ......I think you're 100% correct
he will be up against Andile Jali, Onyekachi Okonkwo, Thandani Ntshumayelo and Manti Moholo in Bucs' defensive midfield role
...........................................................................................................................................................................

Since Andile Jali is no longer going to join Germany team next to Garankuwa ,after robots ,opposite SPAR Supermarket .......the chances of Viera playing regulr are very slim.

However I hope its gonna create a healthy competition.
ProudSAcan
posted: 12:15 pm
Wrong move or right move for the boy the decision has been made. He is a Pirate now. I believe the same song was sung when Pirates signed Moholo and Makola. Are those players forever warming the bench TTM? You are running high with emotions right now I see!
KING?
posted: 12:16 pm

Tiyani wa ka Mabasa, so u have concluded that Viera cannot compete at this level. The fact that he stand out in the entire under 20 role, means the boy is up to task.

You have also ignored the structural change factor, Pirates could use 3 defensive minded players at once, a system they have used in Kroll's time eg Chansa,Jali,ACE with Ngobeni coming as a sub.

Best teams in the world have great players competing in the same role.
Animal1
posted: 12:18 pm
@By Tiyani wa ka Mabasa
was it necessary to show us that u r one of the Zebra's? its a pity cos u can't do anything about his decision. This boy want to win and he had to associate himself with the champs...

Khosiologyst ...2013/14 Maintaining The Glory
posted: 12:18 pm
El Kampionposted: 12:15 pm | Report
@Tiyani

I see you are one of the bitter Zebra fans...

You said the same thing about Jali when he came to Galaxy

Manqele as well

You guys can go hang yourselves with a spider web,this boy is a Buccaneer now so deal with it
============================================================================
Mr Augusto "El-Kampion" Palcious, can you please please please for once not be an animal and not use your MOTETE and use your brains . Please Sir.
apnesamvuni
posted: 12:18 pm
Wrong move inndeed, Pie-rats hd lot of stars in that position, it was supposed to be gud move if joined chips
Chief Hlabarinto
posted: 12:18 pm
Insult him(Tiyani) MaBuccaneer...
I don't think this guy was gona walk striaght into the KCFC starting line-up judging by Baxter's team selection, he was going to be on the bench together with Salt & Vinegar plus Sheriff until Yeye gets suspension or gets injured. But dont get me wrong he is a good player though, i wont ask what he has achieved with Wits or about his failed overseas move just like our noisy Gorillas who questions every player who is signed by other teams except theirs
Football Brains
posted: 12:18 pm
Great article Tiyani. It's interesting to see what the stats will say come end of the season. We at Football Brains (www.facebook.com/footballbrains) will be watching the space closely.
makgorometsa
posted: 12:19 pm
he just kissed his promising career gudbye.
Terms of use:

The comments posted do not reflect the views of KickOff.com. Users are reminded that no misuse of this comment facility will be tolerated. Any abusive, racist or inflammatory comments will be deleted and the user banned.

Please report abusive posts to editor@kickoff.com. Logged in users can select "report" next to the offending comment.

S.A's leading price comparison site