Irvin Khoza

Sanef blasts PSL over new competition

South African National Editors' Forum blasts PSL over new competition

Posted: 14 August 2012 Time: 08:57 am

The South African National Editors' Forum (Sanef) has objected to the new Premier Soccer League competition for soccer reporters.

PSL chairman Irvin Khoza announced the new competition on Friday where winners who correctly predicts the outcome of matches will be rewarded with R500 000 for each of the three categories; print, television and radio after the end of each quarter, with the new season having been divided into four quarters. Quarter one will have eight fixtures and so forth.

Sanef have released a statement, saying the new competition for the reporters doesn’t only violate the journalism code, but also undermines the ethics of the profession.

“Sanef wishes to place on record that it was not party to this ‘extensive’ consultation process, nor is it aware of any other credible industry bodies that were consulted about this competition,” the statement reads.

“Had Sanef been consulted, we would have made it clear to the PSL that the competition undermines the ethics of our profession. This competition seeks to turn journalists who use their skills to report and analyse football into gamblers.

“It risks opening the door for corrupt practices which our profession has no desire to be part of. Equating this competition with other awards is disingenuous. Genuine journalism awards reward excellence and hard work.

“The proposed competition is also a direct violation of our professional codes, which state that journalists should avoid conflicts of interest and ‘arrangements or practices that could lead audiences to doubt the press' independence and professionalism’.

“However, should journalists wish to participate in lotteries and sweepstakes in their individual capacities they are free to do so. But this cannot be done under the guise of professional work. Journalists are not allowed to use their roles in media outlets - broadcast, print and digital - for gambling purposes.”

Sanef says it will be seeking a meeting with the PSL to voice their concerns about this competition and “its potentially corrosive impact on journalism and media ethics”.

Article by: Tiyani wa ka Mabasa

Add New Comment

Comments Login Form

Forgotten your password?

Your comments on this story...

Champ Nebo
posted: 09:06 am

Dat 's really toilet, i also think we are out of line now, really if we had enough money Ydon't dey just increase de first division grant. or evem even investing with sports academy will stil be fine dan dat Shit.
KingMay
posted: 09:06 am
Ja nerh, then please tell your useless journos not to enter the competition. PSL please donate the money charities that actually need it!
jshongwe
posted: 09:10 am
I dont see any poblem with that as journos are already taking bribes from teams anyway!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Donald Duck
posted: 09:15 am
I agree, this is complete bullsh*T. Jurnos will win 1.5 mill per quarter, that's 6mill per season?? I might as well be a jurnalist to win half-a-million rands. why not increase the price money for the psl? or use it to subsidise tickets so we pay less? or better yet donate the cash to charity? in my opinion jurnalist should not even be allowed to enter such competitions as it's conflict of interest.
thuth teller
posted: 09:18 am
I bet this TOOTHLESS thug has a big cut in all this cake.They have so much they cant even think of sane ways of spending it,Why not spend it on our Developments Academies.Invest in young talents you Mongrols.and Mr Coweditor please use another photo not this one.UYASGXIGXIZA LOBABA NGO 7
Donald Duck
posted: 09:23 am
i think sponsores like vodacom should look at reducing their contributions cause their money's are being mis-used. last nite the teams gave away 2mill on soccer zone. I dont mind winning prices but i think there must be a limit to such things.
tebotouch
posted: 09:29 am
lol.... Speaking of preffisionalism
like realy sanef???
You guys here @ south africa dont come close to that
be it , print-media / internet media...
All u know is destroy pipo's lives n take side's mxm. Baseless !!! De hafajees. Of diz world
Mister not so nice guy
posted: 09:33 am
That jounalist called "superjurno" is lame and he has issues with players like Benni
Viny da Vincy
posted: 09:38 am
Dr. Khoza wale Sundowns
The Phefeni Boy
posted: 09:38 am
Most of our players are busy being exploited by certain teams within the PSL by being paid the so called entry-level salaries and here we want to turn a blind eye on that situation and start paying journos for predicting scores?....some players from some teams in the PSL are so poor they can even afford to buy car to take them to and from work yet we see them on the TV week in week out glorifying the PSL brand...

Bin Laden
posted: 09:48 am
DR Khoza must step down,,,Finish and Klaar,,he has turned the PSL into his own political party..Nxa
Dooba (Glory Reclaimed)
posted: 09:49 am
Hey, someone there at Sanef has done his homework, it is not like your objection will henceforth begin doing justice on the bias and many uninformed so-called objective opinions of our local journos... they are as clueless as the Iron Duke himself... speaking of this toothless devil, what was he thinking to even have incompetent people whom we expect to be objective all the time to take part in petty "get rich quickly" scheme. Dividing the league to quarter was a good idea, a good incentive at least, but involving juornos and trusting them with predictions is recipe for disaster.

If the journos failed to read the CAF rules, how do you expect them to read what has not even happened?
thokozani.mabindisa
posted: 09:52 am
yeah that was totaly wrong big up to sanef u can not change my job now that u got a money big up!!
Dooba (Glory Reclaimed)
posted: 09:54 am
Bin Laden:
I couldnt agree with that more. Conflict of interest! The PSL hot seat should rotate, maybe money will stop dissappearing in the name of bonuses... no wonder the Prez does not play far from Dr. Dukes... I wont be surprised if in the near future their relationship would be declared "corrupt", just like many others we know but cant tell.
Makwera KhosiFIED
posted: 09:54 am
Typical of Khoza Mafia tactics....

We all know very well that PSL won't be having a CEO since Khoza is running the show. He's going to soon appoint himself as Chairman and CEO>>>>>>watch this space.

And you wonder why THEY CLAIM TO BE TREBLE CHAMPS!!!!!!

FACT: CONFLICT OF INTERESTS IS ONLY WORKING FOR ORLANDO PIRATES!!!!!
Dikotsi
posted: 09:59 am
I agree with SANEF. This is a very stupid competition together with its set up.
Rather, they should introduce the one competition that will encourage sports journalistic creativeness to draw spectators to matches 9 since some clubs are doing dismally in this department and , not this nonsense.
tmgqweto
posted: 10:02 am
Let the baboons dance
tmgqweto
posted: 10:04 am
psl under khoza is a real joke where is the development
De Bruin!!!
posted: 10:07 am
This is interesting. Really interesting.
Percinator
posted: 10:09 am
Champ "Superbrand", Jika, BBM17 i dnt c ur comments on dis issue as u wer fo eva praising Dr Khoza doings so lets hear ur comments
Terms of use:

The comments posted do not reflect the views of KickOff.com. Users are reminded that no misuse of this comment facility will be tolerated. Any abusive, racist or inflammatory comments will be deleted and the user banned.

Please report abusive posts to editor@kickoff.com. Logged in users can select "report" next to the offending comment.

S.A's leading price comparison site