HOME - Kick Off South Africa - Africa's biggest soccer site
 HOME - Kick Off South Africa - Africa's biggest soccer site
 
Namibia move could derail Afcon 2012
 

The 2012 Africa Cup of Nations could be thrown into chaos

Namibia move could derail Afcon 2012

Posted: 2011-11-01 07:46

The 2012 Africa Cup of Nations could be thrown into chaos after Namibia pledged to take their protest over Burkina Faso's involvement to the Court of Arbitration for Sport.  

On Friday, the Confederation of African Football dismissed Namibia's appeal over the eligibility of Burkina Faso's Herve Zengue on a technicality. 
 
But the Namibians maintain that CAF is ignoring one of its own rulings, which states that any team fielding a 'non-qualified player' should still lose a match regardless of any protest.
 
The Namibian FA has told the BBC it will first appeal to CAF and, if necessary, the Court of Arbitration for Sport afterwards. 
 
Article 36.12 states that a team which allows a ‘non-qualified or a suspended player to take part in group matches shall lose the match by penalty (3-0), even in the absence of protests/reservations'. 
 
Cameroon-born Zengue appeared in two matches for Burkina Faso during the 2012 Nations Cup qualifiers, both of which resulted in victories over Namibia. 
 
However, had Namibia been awarded the points - since they believe Zengue to be ineligible to play for Burkina Faso since he has yet to receive a Fifa clearance - then the Brave Warriors would have qualified for the finals. 
 
This is because the six points from two technical 3-0 victories would have seen them finish Group F with an unsurpassed nine points - five more than the Burkinabes' revised total. 
 
"For us, it is very clear that the reason it took so long to arrive at what appears to be a simple decision is because people were looking for technicalities," Barry Rukoro, the General Secretary of the Namibian FA, told BBC Sport. 
 
Rukoro stresses that his organisation did indeed follow the ruling. 
 
"We approached the match commissioner before the match, who directed us to the match referee. Before kick-off, the two captains were called, they signed the protest and the documents were taken by the referee," he explained.
 
"If the referee did not submit those documents as part of his document, it should not be our problem as we are not the ones appointing the referee.
 
"It is not only a case of us wanting to play at the Nations Cup but a case that this thing is happening all over the continent," he said. "I think that some of our smaller associations are being disadvantaged by these kinds of actions.
 
"We are going to appeal in terms of the regulations to CAF but even if that appeal does not succeed, because we believe we have a very good case, we will go all the way to the Court of Arbitration for Sport. 
 
"Some people presume that because we are a small national association, we can be trampled on and we will do nothing. I think it is high time that we spent some of the resources that we would have spent on development on enforcing people to come clean." 






To comment please [login] or [register]

Comment on this article:

TERMS OF USE: The comments posted below do not reflect the views of KickOff.com. Users are reminded that no misuse of this comment facility will be tolerated. Any abusive, racist or inflammatory comments will be deleted and the user banned. Please report abusive posts to editor@kickoff.com


Recent Comments (13) :

bmygal: 2011-11-01 08:47

go for it Nam's, at least you have a real case.

critic: 2011-11-01 08:51

Yeah go Namibia, this people tend to overlook their own rules on many occasions. Never let go off their tail.

samr: 2011-11-01 10:00

CAF must learn to treat all associations in Africa equally and must unfavourably abide by it's ruling. It was so quick to announce to Africa about Bafana as if somebody has been delegated to check that ruling against us but it takes forever to rule against Burkina Faso which is affected by article 36.12.

Ben: 2011-11-01 10:45

Honestly,how can CAF ignore its own rules!!!!Namibia show CAF that you understand English better than them.All the procedure was followes but CAF tend to ignore and favor some countries but then why must it be like that.CAF,it time we cleaned your office of unfavoorable decisions for the progression of the game of football on the continentof Africa.

The Ghost: 2011-11-01 10:45

Halala ... the gloves are off; let the games begin!!!

Kaumba: 2011-11-01 10:55

But the Namibians maintain that CAF is ignoring one of its own rulings, which states that any team fielding a 'non-qualified player' should still lose a match regardless of any protest.

this is clear....they were Laughing at SA for failing to read the rules now it is their turn...nomore technicalities and thanks to namibia for picking up this im sure a lot of countries expecialy west African do this and goes unpanished....i don't think this is the first time burkina faso did this.....

Kaumba: 2011-11-01 10:57

And Y does CAF hate Southern Africans....They hardly award us the right to host The CAN.....

critic: 2011-11-01 11:40

Either this case is reasonably resolved or no CAN tournament next year....we are tired of the dictatorship within the African governing body. Hulle moet reg kom of weg kom man!

fmsouthafrica: 2011-11-01 13:43

I urge SAFA to support the Namibian association, especially considering Burkina fielded the non-eligible player in the friendly against Bafana too. We should've protested then, but we won the game, and there was of course all the controversy about Burkina players not honoring call-ups for that game, and SAFA being blamed.
Its time CAF realized that Fair Play should be their no 1 priority. African football is synonymous with under-handed tactics whether it be ref (&player) intimidation, bribery, over-age players in youth competitions, unruly and unsporting fans e.g. Egyptians shining lasers in opponents eyes throughout fixtures. These sorts of things need action from CAF. Some things need more investigation e.g. how can Niger win at home consistently yet have not won a competitive away match since 1992?
Namibia have a case, a case they should win, would be great to see CAF for once, doing the right thing.
Even, with regards to the ruling that saw Bafana not qualifying, which was introduced because of the possibility of the bottom team "throwing" a result and allowing their opponent a possible 10-0 score which would effect goal difference. Rather than punish a team for that, they made the rule to seemingly ignore fixed results.
Come on CAF, fix African soccer!

fmsouthafrica: 2011-11-01 13:48

I urge SAFA to support the Namibian association, especially considering Burkina fielded the non-eligible player in the friendly against Bafana too. We should've protested then, but we won the game, and there was of course all the controversy about Burkina players not honoring call-ups for that game, and SAFA being blamed.
Its time CAF realized that Fair Play should be their no 1 priority. African football is synonymous with under-handed tactics whether it be ref (&player) intimidation, bribery, over-age players in youth competitions, unruly and unsporting fans e.g. Egyptians shining lasers in opponents eyes throughout fixtures. These sorts of things need action from CAF. Some things need more investigation e.g. how can Niger win at home consistently yet have not won a competitive away match since 1992?
Namibia have a case, a case they should win, would be great to see CAF for once, doing the right thing.
Even, with regards to the ruling that saw Bafana not qualifying, which was introduced because of the possibility of the bottom team "throwing" a result and allowing their opponent a possible 10-0 score which would effect goal difference. Rather than punish a team for that, they made the rule to seemingly ignore fixed results.
Come on CAF, fix African soccer!

Mr T: 2011-11-01 18:01

never take things for granted,CAF you have no whr to hinde on this one.look into the case and act base on merit,technicality for wht u CAF.Namibia need to prepare for the competition so don,nt take so long on this.

kamangete: 2011-11-10 11:33

caf will definitely learn a lesson from , they wont go away with this that is what we call daylight robbery

kamangete: 2011-11-10 11:34

caf will definitely learn a lesson from this , they wont go away with this that is what we call daylight robbery

 
Kickoff Subscribe
ADVERTISING