My problem with local coaches

My problem with local coaches

Posted: 15 August 2010 Time: 09:11 am

First of all, apologies for the 'break in transmission'. It was occasioned by World Cup duties in the first instance, then matters of a more filial nature in the second. 

While I was running around at the World Cup in South Africa, my wife and I had an addition to the family. It felt a bit weird not being there for the birth of my daughter, so it was understandable that immediately I got back from South Africa, I took a break and headed off to the USA to see my kid.   It has been more than fulfilling taking a break from football, especially Nigerian football after the disaster that was South Africa 2010.   While I have kept away from actively being involved, that does not mean I did not follow events closely (I couldn't keep away if I tried).   But in the weeks since the tournament, things have been going in the direction that we all sort of expected.   The NFF's key leadership trio have been impeached, certain Super Eagles players have been 'retired' from the team, Lars Lagerback has refused to return to Nigeria's House of Commotion, elections into the NFF have generated a dozen different kinds of controversy and a new coach (read Samson Siasia) is about to be appointed.   There is more than enough in all these and others issues to write an opus, and I promise I will deal with all of them in time.   But for now, the more immediate issue is that of the appointment of a coach.   After the Berti Vogts debacle in Ghana, some of the folks from the NFF asked for my opinion about a new coach. My response was that we should go local.   But I put a caveat in that recommendation. I told them of my fears with the appointment of a local coach, and pointed out things that needed to be done to ensure that said coach stayed within the bounds of ethical and professional behavior.   At the time, my choice for the position was Stephen Keshi, for what he had achieved since venturing into coaching, first as assistant to Shuaibu Amodu, and then his success with Togo.   However, my worry was in the way Nigerian coaches conduct business. I have had too many firsthand experiences of coaches receiving 'gifts' from players, agents and certain other characters.   There have also been instances of coaches blatantly getting involved in player management matters that they have no right to.   Don't get me wrong. Coaches elsewhere do the same. But where those others may employ the services of third parties to cover their trails, there is a blatant disregard for secrecy in the way our coaches go about what should be a clandestine activity. A business that is at best illicit, and at worst criminal.   In the end, we pass it off with one of those hackneyed sayings of 'where a man works is where he eats'.   And in some twisted justification, maybe it is not entirely their fault.   Nigerian (and other African indigenous coaches) are some of the worst remunerated in the world.   As an example, look at the pay disparity between Shuaibu Amodu and Lars Lagerback.   Where Amodu was paid a measly $15000 a month sans perks, Lagerback was paid $200 000 plus perks.   Or we can go slightly back. Austin Eguavoen was paid less than $10 000 a month, without perks while Berti Vogts, who usurped him, got $50 000 with all the perks he wanted.   Additionally, the foreign coaches get the job security afforded by watertight contracts and are allowed the leeway to do just about anything they want.   The local coach is second-guessed at every turn.   What this leads to generally is a coach who is.   1. Not in control of his team, and gradually sees his respect eroded in the eyes of the players 2. Is continually worried about his future and tries to make as much money as possible by whatever means he can using his position, while he still has it   Some have argued that the local coaches are so desperate for the jobs that they accept whatever they are offered without a fuss.   That may be true, but the coaches also argue that they do it in the national interest.   All that is beside the point of this argument. The key issue here is that because the indigenous coaches are so poorly paid and compromised, they can barely make the decisions that would be in the best interest of the team and nation.   These were the issues I spoke about in 2008, and I told them that in appointing a local coach, the key issue of adequate remuneration and the colloquial 'free hand' should be allowed the new coach.   That, as it turns out, did not happen.   And so, as we all understand that the NFF are negotiating with Siasia, my point is that irrespective of whether we feel he is the right candidate for the job or not, both Siasia and the NFF should address these issues properly in his contract.   First, Siasia should settle for nothing less than the $50 000 paid to Vogts. He must also insist on the various other add-ons that will allow him to do his job properly, including whatever assistants he feels he will need to deliver.   We should also consider the Brazil model, where the coaches are appointed in a four-year cycle, culminating in the World Cup.   That allows the coach time to build a team from scratch and impose his own imprint on them.   In our case, I would suggest a two-year contract with the option of renewal for another two years conditional on certain key performance indicators achievable within the initial two-year period.   By the same token, the NFF must include in his contract, a clause that he will stay away from any activities that might be considered underhand.   It may not be entirely enough, but it is a start.     STAR WARS: ATTACK OF THE EX INTERNATIONALS   We are in a real Star Wars scenario where the former stars (pun fully intended) have decided to take over the administrative reins of our football.   While I have no objection to ex internationals wanting to be involved in the running of the game, I want to caution that being a good player is neither a necessary nor sufficient condition to be a good administrator.   Examples abound all over the world.   I told my good friend Victor Ikpeba the same thing just before I left for the US. These ex internationals wanting to 'take over the world' must earn the right to be where they are headed for.   Otherwise, the danger is that if they come in enmasse and fail to make the change that people want, they would have closed the door on future generations.   Anyway, my friend China Acheru has written what I consider an excellent piece on the issue.    While I do not entirely agree with everything he said there, I think his idea of devil's advocate should get us all thinking.          

Article by: Colin Udoh

Add New Comment

Comments Login Form

Forgotten your password?

Your comments on this story...

Anonymous
posted: 09:31 am
First and foremost, congrats on the birth of your daughter Colin. How is the sleepless nights going for you? Maybe you didnt feel it so much since you were in SA during the birth. God's blessings to your entire family.

It is extremely difficult making comments regarding Nigerian football. It has reached a level where one continuously expect the usual (worst) to happen. Unfortunately, most Nigerians think about how every decision impacts on their financial benefits rather than the good of the nation. Additionally, we have sold our souls and hearts to the white skinned people.

The best intentioned people get carried away as soon as they ascend a position of power in Nigeria. We do not trust ourselves. We are also bedevilled by ethnic and religious problems. The list is endless.

Siasia may not catch the fancy of every Nigerian, but if Nigerians were to vote, Siasia will win a landslide vote. He has showned in the past that he is a man of action. A disciplinarian. Just like the wish of most Nigerians, the rebuilding of the Super Eagles should be handed over to Siasia. It may take time, but if he is given a free hand, we might notice the changes in the team sooner than later.

"Que sera sera... whatever will be will be".
Anonymous
posted: 10:22 am
Congratulations Colin on your newly born daughter and its good to see that the forum is gradually coming back to life.

While I agree with your views on renumeration for our coaches, permit me to point out that all over the world, the wage demands of expatriates are usually on the high side when compared to their local counterparts. This can be attributed to several factors which I believe you are aware of. I don't therefore subscribe to the school of thought that blasts foreign coaches for earning so much as every pofessional is entitled to make his wage demands. It's left for the hiring party to accept or reject them.

A question I`d like to ask is..how many of our local coaches are licenced by UEFA? (I mean grade A certification). Our local coaches do not see the need to go for refresher courses abroad. They sit down, complain, and hope that the black coach / white coach debate would steer sentiments towards their direction, thereby landing them jobs with any of our national sides.

Steve Mclaren of England, after beiing relieved of his duty as England manager, rather than sit down and wallow in self-pity (just as our dear Amodu is doing at the moment), left for Holland to take up new challenges where his hardwork culminated in the 2010 Eredivise victory with FC Twente. He is currently the coach of Wolfsburg and is still highly sought after in Europe. LET OUR COACHES DEVELOP THEMSELVES.
Anonymous
posted: 11:10 am
congratulations colins, on your new born baby.

Anonymous
posted: 11:47 am
Congratulations on ur newly born . May God provide all that is needed for the proper growth.
On the aspect of Nigerian football, all we need is a change....it does need to start from the root and it does not matter how long it takes to re-build the senior team.
Anonymous
posted: 12:26 pm
@Colin, good article and congratulations - insisting that siasia should go for nothing less than the $50,000 paid berti voghts could cost him the job. In as much as we all want him to get the job, there's need to be reasonable. In my opinion, I believe 6million Naira or $40,000 a month is just ok. If he gets beyond that, it's a rip off considering that contracts can be reviewed upwards when excellent performance calls for it.
nano
posted: 01:06 pm
congratz mr. colin, you are richly blessed, the lil girl and the mum will remain strong and healthy,
welcome fully to kon, i agree with every bit of ur opinion, all i ask siasia is to be himself, he should no settle for anything less than 50grand, and other add ons, he should know that if they dont give him the job today, we nigerians will yell on the government till he has it, so he should not sell his right to money...period
sunshine4life
posted: 01:31 pm
1st and foremost,congrat collins for the newborn.Regarding d feel d nff is willing to pay sia1,2m is way too low for is status,4 crying out loud we nt talking of U17,21,23 or any underage grade team coach here,bt SE,2m is low sia1 1 shd consider 5m for a start wit increasement option in d contract regarding is performances.
Anonymous
posted: 01:50 pm
Congratulations Colins!
As an aside, whether on TV, pages of magazines or Internet, I've always considered you to be one of the best.
More grease to your elbows.
Anonymous
posted: 01:51 pm
Congratulations Colin!
As an aside - whether on TV, pages of magazine or the web, I've always considered you one of the very best.
More grease to your elbows.
Anonymous
posted: 01:58 pm
It is absolutely crazy to offer the head coach of the Super Eagles a paltry N3million per month as salary, when a technical adviser from europe was paid $200000 for about 6 weeks of real work. Lagerback did not do anything with the Super Eagles until about 2 weeks before the World Cup.

This situation boils down to the fact that we do not value our own people. It has always been a problem for selfish NFF officials. Siasia should not accept anything less than N48million per year and his renumeration should include official cars and drivers, official residence, bonuses and allowances etc. He should also be given a long term contract of 4 years to be reviewed every 2 years. He should be provided with a functioning office and staff with current technology to monitor performance of his players rather than newspaper reports. He should be projected to have involvement in his players' conditions through partnerships with their clubs for medical and performance statistics they keep about the players.

Siasia's performance should also be measured and specific metrics and KPIs should be boldly stated in his contract with penalties for non-performance. Penalties could be termination of contract, reduction of allowances or salary etc.

That way the NFF would have given him all he needs to work and themselves the opportunity to give him the sack if he does not perform as expected.

It is that simple.
Kolawole1
posted: 02:18 pm
Congrats on the birth of your new baby girl, but when next you choose to score such a beautiful spot kick, make sure there is somebody delegated the task of keeping this webpage running so that there is no gap in information flow.....

Be that as it may, i dont agree with you that the 'little' wage paid our coaches is the main reason why they engage in such sharp pratices. A coach, or any professional for that matter is only worth his/her credentials i.e. whatever he has invested in himself. Our local coaches are frequently not as qualified as their Oyinbo counterparts neither are they so experienced, it is a fallacious to argue we must pay them same with the expatriate coacjes simply because they are our countrymen. That is encouraging mediocrity! There are hordes of Nigerian graduates in all fileds going abroad for their postgraduate studies on their own bill so as to return home as valuable finished products, attracting fantastic pay packages from multinational companies. If they(Coaches) want to earn more let them them invest more in themselves.

Also, we have to purge ourselves of this cankerworm of corruption. You will be surprised that quite a number of Nigerian coaches will still get involved in racketeering even when paid the same amount as Berti Vogts or Lagerback. Are our legislators not earning more than Barack Obama? yet are they still not stealing our commonwealth?
Anonymous
posted: 02:44 pm
CONGRAT!!!!!!!!!! COLLINS...
Y1NKA
posted: 04:43 pm
▌▌♥

Congrats COL!N

Lets just hope its the birth of new era of beautiful things with SIA SIA in charge. The future surely looks very bright !!!

▌▌♥
Anonymous
posted: 11:36 pm
For those who are thinking or even entertaining the notion that being a good footballer as nothing to do with being a good administrator, my answer to you is this, who would you votes for? Someone who know what it takes to develop a footballer from grassroots to the finish article. Who do you want to develop our coaches through all the level there is to be a better coach, someone that will sent them abroad on a regular basis to improve them, and the NFF don’t have the money for that, then someone who can use his influence through UEFA and FIFA to bring the top coaches down to Naija on a regular basis under some umbrella for football development in Africa. WHO WOULD YOU VOTE FOR, some Alhaji from the north who knows almost nothing about football or an ex international who have played for Ajax, Regina, Juventus, Borusia Dortmund, Inter Milan, Ac Milan, Barcelona, Arsenal and Chelsea. Yes these are the type of experience we`ve got in this country and fail to tap them, because we are all suffering from the Juju which corrupt people had place on us, which stop`s us from seeing sense, and if anyone should have the audacity to talk sense, our response, how dear him talk sense, we should shout him down and bombard him with stupidity. We have ex players in this country, People who have seen how white people do it, at the highest level, throughout Europe. WHO WOULD YOU VOTE FOR?
objective bibby
posted: 02:40 am
Congrats Colin..Wish mother & baby sound health.
@ Kolawole1, always spot on & intelligent analysis. Nothing to add. May u live long!!!
Anonymous
posted: 10:34 am
the problem with NIgerian football goes beyond the appointment of local coaches and pay disparity between their foreign counterparts. Few weeks ago Adebayo on BBC asked why so many WA countries rely on foreign coaches . He said in his own personal opinion - and he is not short of many , there for now remain the best option until they become a bit more professional. You recall his spat with our own Stephen Keshi. It is like corruption in Nigeria we can't see it but we know it is there.

On this forum I predicted that Amodu will be sacked and a foreingn manager will be appointed and he will also go. The failures go beyond the personalities - it is our culture of work , values and national pridethat sticks. Lars has not just become a bad cpach- if pressed he would confess that the working environment is not enabling.
An important man recently openly claimed that politicians were putting pressure on the association for team selection and you think a $50,000 to a local coach will be sufficient to ward off such pressure. A foreign coach more likely will. We just pluck figures - who arrived at such a figure and how does that relate to the general micro economic realities of Nigeria. Money is not every thing.

In an era of Zoning glamourised by our ill equiped and naive politicians - the issue of national ethno-centric balance in the National team has always been the albatross of local coaches - a foreign coach is more likely to resist these pressures.

All the underhand deals again will be less likely get the support of Foreign coach.

Our so called exemplary local coaches all performed well in age group competitions where as more often the case colluded with age cheats more for their own personal glories than the nations.

my submission is that we are still not ripe for a local coach for the national team.We have to take long term view in planning and team building . 2014 is not far away. we debated all these in 2002, 2006 and again 2010.

So long as petty personal interest is allowed above national interest as is so often the case in all our national endeavours so long shall we put up with pitiful , abject performances as displayed in the recent shameful outing in SA.
A2J4
posted: 10:45 am
We would have been away from football if President Jonathan had stuck to his guns. We should, in my opinion, still have a two years non expectation from the senior team in our mind and rebuild the team. Our worst enemy is our unripe expectation from the team so even the appointment of Siasia will carry a whole lot of quick win expectation that lead us to another call for his head. I will propose that his contract should have no quick win expectation for two years with the media agreeing and reminding every one all the time in those two years. If the result comes good fine but no undue pressure.
Anonymous
posted: 12:27 pm
Congratulations!!!
I must commend you, Collin, for this wonderful article. The truth is not far at all from all you've said. I only hope those in authority and the local coaches will learn.

On the issue of what Siasia should be paid if giving the job to be Super Eagles coach. I, probably for the first time on this forum, would want to agree with Billion. But, I will add that if the NFF can afford $30,000 per month, he should accept it. We should stop commpairing this with what Lagerback was being paid. Lagerback was only giving a very short contract and was paid monthly by PTF. We all know that there is no way NFF can afford to pay such an amount. Even Berti Vogts salary, that some even reffered to, was sponsored by Glo. Even when his contract was terminated, It took NFF a long time to pay him off.
What I'm trying to say is that Siasia should accept what NFF can conviniently pay without delay or we might just have the same situation that Collin talked about, coaches becoming businessmen.
Anonymous
posted: 05:01 am
its a pity that when it comes to employing our local coaches, the stakes are lowered. Just imagine Lars pocketing 300k while Siasia is now being offered 20k per month.... Now i see clearly that Nigeria is not ready to move forward. We cannot continue to call the name of GOD to help us when we are not seen doing the right thing. Only the Just live by FAITH. I can see why many good nigerians abroad have simply refused to come back home to offer their services. What a shame.

THE JUST SHALL LIVE BY FAITH
Anonymous
posted: 05:25 am
Hey Collins, congrats on the new baby gal. I didnt even notice that in your piece, i went straight to look at your analysis not until i saw several congratulatory messages. Better late than never so I wish your new born baby all da best.

THE JUST SHALL LIVE BY FAITH
Terms of use:

The comments posted do not reflect the views of KickOff.com. Users are reminded that no misuse of this comment facility will be tolerated. Any abusive, racist or inflammatory comments will be deleted and the user banned.

Please report abusive posts to editor@kickoff.com. Logged in users can select "report" next to the offending comment.

S.A's leading price comparison site