HOME - Kick Off South Africa - Africa's biggest soccer site
 HOME - Kick Off South Africa - Africa's biggest soccer site
 
Soweto Derby shines no more
 

Soweto Derby shines no more

Soweto Derby shines no more

Posted: 2010-02-22 10:43

They came, they saw and were disappointed. That sums up the Saturday’s Soweto Derby as it degenerated into another goalless draw at the Orlando Stadium.

The fans came in their numbers, dressed for the part, and created a carnival atmosphere. The weather was also perfect, but the football was lukewarm and in some parts even insipid.

To be fair to Orlando Pirates and Kaizer Chiefs, Saturday’s game, although ending in a goalless draw, was a whole lot better than the sleep-inducing football they served up in the much-hyped first leg, which was like watching paint dry.

This weekend’s clash had some sporadic moments that created a crazy, nervy and frantic affair. Itumeleng Khune’s double save from Lucas Thwala’s glancing headers and substitute Nkosinathi Nhleko’s rasping shot which ricocheted off the post and then Knowledge Musona’s shot that went agonizingly wide towards the end of the game had fans on the edge of their seats.

Andile Jali shining like a diamond in Pirates’ midfield, up-staging Reneilwe Letsholonyane, was exciting, but how Pirates failed to penetrate an Amakhosi defence led by the erratic Valery Nahayo clearly demonstrated Bucs’ lack of cutting edge up-front.

In the end, Chiefs almost stole the points at the death, only for Moeneeb Josephs to pull off a great save.

But, overall, the Soweto Derby has clearly lost its mojo, though Chiefs el supremo Kaizer Motaung would differ with this opinion.

The lack of goals in the Derby was a major let down, despite the fans coming in numbers and tickets being sold out three days before the game.

What is most poignant is the fact that the two Soweto giants’ statures are on a decline; so much that the game now is all about pride rather than honour.

As the Pretoria giants, SuperSport United and Mamelodi Sundowns, race for the Absa Premiership crown, in Soweto, the country’s two most followed teams were playing for pride and, sadly, once again there were no goals to complement the unrivalled passion and support.

Why, one may ask?

Is there a lack of entertaining players?
Critics say the last players that created a vibe and brought the mojo that came to define the Derby were Pirates whizz-kid Steve ‘Chippa’ Lekoelea and Kaizer Chiefs problem child Jabu ‘Shuffle’ Pule. In the current crop, who can you pick as the players to set the scene alight? Sadly, no one.

Are the coaches too negative in their tactics?
The pressure that comes with coaching these two clubs often makes the coaches too cautious in their approach. They go to the matches not to lose, rather than to win. That’s why the games end in goalless draws because it is more about the coaches protecting their jobs because of the significance of the result. Players are restricted from being inventive and individual skill is not permitted, which is one of the reasons that recent foreign coaches are now being accused of having contributed to the Derby becoming a the dull affair.

Why are Pirates struggling?
A team with no out-and-out striker, a right-footed defender played as a left full-back (Lucky Lekgwathi), and management that buys players without coach’s involvement is bound to struggle. Pirates have more than eight midfielders, no proven striker and a coach who seems to have run out of ideas.

Why are Chiefs struggling?
Chiefs lack a playmaker in the calibre of Doctor Khumalo or Ace Khuse; someone who can link play and take responsibility. Letsholonyane has showed flashes of brilliance, but he drifts in and out of the game. And Tinashe Nengomasha is not the player he was a few years ago. Besides a porous-as-a- sieve defence where Valery Nahayo is an accident waiting to happen, Chiefs lack the quality players of years gone by.

Ernest Fakude







To comment please [login] or [register]

Comment on this article:

TERMS OF USE: The comments posted below do not reflect the views of KickOff.com. Users are reminded that no misuse of this comment facility will be tolerated. Any abusive, racist or inflammatory comments will be deleted and the user banned. Please report abusive posts to editor@kickoff.com


Recent Comments (10) :

SIBUSISO: 2010-02-22 12:16

Any one who disagree with the above article will be smoking his dirty socks. Ernest, you have put it the way it is baba, big up.

To add to that with refrence 10 years down the line.....the players today dont want to take responsibility as individuals in the dying moments of the game.

I heard Tebogo on SSP4 saying during their times, a selective part of players will group together and decide what to do if the coach's plan was not working and thats where you would see the flair of this players....Doctor, Khuse, Madida and co doing what they do best

The Collector: 2010-02-22 12:21

Hey Ernest what is a quality player? what makes a player to be Quality? are quality players born that way? Time change thats why the standard of soccer is also changing my man, you guys must give credit where it is Due. Maybe kick off magazine need quality journalists.you need to look at all factors, i mean how many players in both teams are presenting their national teams?
you sound like David Kekana, its useless to comment on something you know nothing about
the game was good.
Khosi By choice not by force

Ole(The Guru): 2010-02-22 13:02

Kaizer can say whatever he want that derby is a waste of time.

Sweyts: 2010-02-22 13:27

Then Kaizer has once again mislead his church members straight to Sion, that's why the ZCC is recording a boost in membership viz days.

The derby died after the miner surfaced, you can blame it on him as well! Damn this Patrick Mosipha moegoe! lol.

DR NDIVHUWO: 2010-02-22 13:32

yeye exciting? maybe i was watching united and eveton. nothing was exciting, ok to be fair, the exciting staff was there, the cabbege, longest loaf, what else? mmmh nothing! Sundowns, Supersport the take over

Thapelo: 2010-02-22 14:30

It is apparent that there is a section of the media and a few "experts" who are trying to downplay the significance of the derby especially kickoff.

As usual the tickets were sold out days before the game. Are we saying the 35000 plus fans who went to orlando stadium and the millions who watched on tv are stupid?

Both chiefs and pirates are not at thier best lately but this does not mean when they meet the match is insignificant. People need to be reminded that our football has evolved. Gone are the days when only chiefs and pirates competed for the best players in the country. Now, Sundowns can purchase any player they desire. If you scrutinize supersport's main players, you would realise that they got these players due to some clever transfer market dealings. Emile Baron, Morgan Gould, Thabo September, Anthony Laffor, Glen Salmon, Jabu Maluleke come to mind.

Ernest, Pirates do have recognised strikers. Katlego Mashego was banging in goals at supersport (at times scoring hatricks as a sub). Mbuyane scored goals at Free State Stars. Terror Fanteni was doing well Macabi Haifa and Ajax. Mabena was a top marksman in mvela in the previous season. No proven striker? Dont think so.

All in all, it was a good game and great atmosphere.

UP THE BUCS, ONCE AND ALWAYS!

Danzo: 2010-02-22 16:28

Itumeleng Khune’s double save from Lucas Thwala’s glancing headers and substitute Nkosinathi Nhleko’s rasping shot which ricocheted off the post and then Knowledge Musona’s shot that went agonizingly wide towards the end of the game had fans on the edge of their seats. That's 4 moments. I say this derby is overated.

an: 2010-02-23 12:40

"but how Pirates failed to penetrate an Amakhosi defence led by the erratic Valery Nahayo clearly demonstrated Bucs’ lack of cutting edge up-front. "..with all due respect Ernst, what kak is this, which game were you watching coz Nahayo played one of his better games, it's sweswe u shd b after, peace.

an: 2010-02-23 12:56

"but how Pirates failed to penetrate an Amakhosi defence led by the erratic Valery Nahayo clearly demonstrated Bucs’ lack of cutting edge up-front. "..with all due respect Ernst, what kak is this, which game were you watching coz Nahayo played one of his better games, it's sweswe u shd b after, peace.

soccerbabe: 2010-02-23 13:38

Ernest Fakude, our soccer has undergone a huge metarmorphisis in the past 2 decades. Our continual comparisons of a Yeye to Doctor or even a Mashego to Sikhosana is unfair.The dynamics of the game have gone beyond those that were applied years ago, the game is more tactical & technical; & with that the Derby will change.

I feel we are being unfair to this generation of players by making such comparisons.Like their predecessors, let's allow them to write their own Derby history in the manner they can & stop being so critical!

The Derby lives on!!!!!!

 
Kickoff Subscribe
ADVERTISING